Dr. Umesh Jain is now exclusively responsible for TotallyADD.com and its content

Reply To: Is that a way for making money or to help ?

Reply To: Is that a way for making money or to help ?2014-09-05T12:35:14+00:00

The Forums Forums What is it? The Neurology Is that a way for making money or to help ? Reply To: Is that a way for making money or to help ?

#125894

Patte Rosebank
Participant
Post count: 1517

@Galin, this gets discussed here every so often.  In 2010, Dr. Jain discussed it in a thread. His verdict:  So far, the evidence does not support Dr. Amen’s claims about SPECT imaging.

Even now, there still hasn’t been enough large-scale, long-term, double-blind scientific study into it, but what there has been, has not produced any evidence that it works.

So far, the only evidence supporting it is anecdotal (people saying, “It worked for me”), which doesn’t count.

A big red flag is that it claims to “heal” or “cure” ADHD.

In most cases, ADHD is a genetic variant, a different brain wiring. You can’t “cure” it, any more than you can permanently change your brown eyes to blue.

All you can do is reduce the symptoms. (Or, to continue the eye-colour analogy, wear blue contact lenses.)

There needs to be more research into this, to prove it one way or the other, especially since people are paying $4000+ for it.

The onus is on its supporters to prove that it works. You can’t prove a negative.

REPORT ABUSE